a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by b_b
b_b  ·  4783 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: There’s more to your DNA than your DNA.
The dawn of epigenetics and RNA interference have somewhat vindicated Lamarck in recent years, although only partly. It has been shown in rat models that stressing out rats leads to stressed out offspring, even when the babies are raised by placid mothers, suggesting that aggression and anxiety can be passed on to offspring without the aid of genes. While its unknown, the epigenetic environment probably is responsible, but I suspect that regulatory RNAs are involved, as well. I know several people who are investigating similar effects with obesity. Can fat beget fat? Probably, is my suspicion. That is a reason I suspect that our current obesity problem is accelerating. Perhaps each generation of successively fatter individuals will have children whose biology makes it more difficult to process calories efficiently.




thundara  ·  4782 days ago  ·  link  ·  
It's an interesting mechanism of regulating cellular metabolism and differentiation, but keep in mind that these are changes to the muscle cells, not the gametes. Unless you can find some correlated methylation in the egg or sperm, these findings aren't quite as meaningful as I think you'd like.

Here's a slightly more interesting and relevant article correlating epigenetics with child development and long-term diseases. I haven't read more than the abstract of it, but you may like it!

b_b  ·  4782 days ago  ·  link  ·  
This is the abstract I was referring to; not the one in the article above.
thundara  ·  4782 days ago  ·  link  ·  
I stand corrected! Didn't pay close attention when scanning your first comment.
mk  ·  4782 days ago  ·  link  ·  
I came here to give Lamarck some props as well. It's incredible to think that my daughter was not only influenced by the genes I was given, but what I have been doing with them.

The stress thing is interesting. Have you noticed that centurions tend to have a very carefree view of things? I have to wonder if their longevity is in part due to a limited ability to experience epigenetically deleterious stress.

b_b  ·  4782 days ago  ·  link  ·  
Centenarians? Centurians were soldiers who commanded groups of 100.

But back to Lamarck. Don't give yourself too much credit :) Probably the wife has more to do with it than you. I think that you both could affect the methylation status of such and such gene, but that she probably has all the cards when it comes to regulatory RNAs and more of the share are transcription factors. Yet another reason to celebrate mothers...even if it is a day late.

mk  ·  4782 days ago  ·  link  ·  
    Centenarians? Centurians were soldiers who commanded groups of 100.

No, I was talking about awesome soldiers, and their positive outlook on life.

    But back to Lamarck. Don't give yourself too much credit :) Probably the wife has more to do with it than you. I think that you both could affect the methylation status of such and such gene, but that she probably has all the cards when it comes to regulatory RNAs and more of the share are transcription factors. Yet another reason to celebrate mothers...even if it is a day late.

You think? I would guess that the sperm factory is very susceptible to what is going on day to day, -maybe not regulatory RNAs so much, but who knows? Well, at least I chose the sex (meaning male or female).

b_b  ·  4782 days ago  ·  link  ·  
Well, the female has most of the cytoplasm. An very conservative approximation is the egg is a sphereoid of ~150um diameter and the sperm about 5um, a factor of 30, making the volumetric ratio a 900:1; or, there's a lot more shit in there to influence what happens.

    Well, at least I chose the sex (meaning male or female)

I hope that everyone just assumed this is what you meant, and you didn't have to qualify in the parentheses. If any of you didn't, then you should seek psychological help...immediately.